Welcome to Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill
At Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill, the charm of a rustic eatery meets culinary innovation. With a warm, casual atmosphere perfect for families or gatherings, it caters to diverse palates, boasting a menu rich in fresh seafood and expertly grilled steaks. Highlights include the succulent shrimp scampi and the dry-aged T-bone steak, both of which have garnered rave reviews for their flavor and portion sizes. Diners can enjoy a game-filled ambiance that complements delightful dining with friendly service. Sammy's stands out as a place where affordability does not compromise quality, ensuring a memorable experience for every guest.
Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill: Reviews & Ratings
The closest I've probably ever came to becoming Violently Ill in public from over-consumption. Absolutely demolished a shrimp scampi entree, a penne vodka entree, a sirloin burger, 2 orders of fries, and 2 desserts (cheesecake/mint chip ice cream and apple crumb/vanilla ice cream). Made a bet with my wife before the bill came and we were both off by 50% thinking it would be more. Phenomenal price for the quantity and quality!
I wish I could express how much I genuinely enjoyed this place and the experience. You order as soon as you walk in and the hostess realized we weren't regulars and took a few extra minutes to guide us through the whole experience. We placed our order and headed to the bar in the basement, where we played arcade games and had a drink. Once we were called back up, we were greeted with a yummy salad, followed by our app of penne a la vodka. It was WONDERFUL. I mean we destroyed that plate it was so good. For entrees I had the shrimp scampi and my boyfriend had the strip. Both were cooked to perfection. Prices were more reasonable than a normal steakhouse and we both walked out fully satisfied.
Location
-
353 Mendham Rd W, Mendham Township, NJ 07945 Hotline: (973) 543-7675
Welcome to Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill, a hidden gem nestled at 353 Mendham Rd W, Mendham Township, NJ 07945. This delightful establishment embodies the classic charm of a steakhouse while offering an eclectic menu that caters to both carnivores and vegetarians alike. It's the perfect spot for dinner with family or friends, where the hearty laughter and camaraderie create an infectious atmosphere.
One of the most remarkable aspects of Sammy's is the sheer variety of dishes on offer. From the enticing Red Roasting Peppers with oil and garlic priced at just $5.00, to the indulgent Two Whole Maine Lobsters at $52.00, each item promises a memorable culinary experience. Customer favorites like the Shrimp Scampi Sammys Style and Dry Aged T-Bone Steak showcase the skill and passion of the kitchen staff, making each bite a celebration of flavor.
- Appetizers: Start your meal with the Vodka Pasta or the classic Lobster Cocktail.
- Entrees: Savor the 16 Oz. New York Strip Steak Bone-In or indulge in the comforting 2 Double Cut Pork Chops with apple sauce.
- Vegetarian Options: Don’t miss the Oil And Garlic Spaghetti, which is perfect for those looking for meat-free choices.
The ambiance at Sammy's is both casual and lively, making it ideal for larger groups, families, and even pets, as they welcome dogs to join you. The restaurant provides excellent utilities, including outdoor seating and Wi-Fi, ensuring a welcoming atmosphere for everyone. With options for delivery and takeout, indulging in their delectable fare is easy, no matter your schedule.
Given its vibrant atmosphere and inviting service, it's no surprise that patrons rave about their experiences. One enthusiastic review from John M. highlighted the generous portion sizes and remarkable value, proclaiming, "Phenomenal price for the quantity and quality!" Meanwhile, Sarah M. celebrated the friendly guidance of the staff and the delightful flavors of her meal, particularly the penne a la vodka. The positive energy of the room is palpable, often filled with laughter and joy as new guests discover the culinary delights arranged before them.
If you’re seeking not just a meal but an experience, Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill offers both. Prepare yourself for a flavorful journey, tantalizing dishes, and a welcoming environment that feels like home. Make a reservation today at (973) 543-7675, and take a step back into a time where good food and great company reign supreme.
